Dont remove inspection contingency before fully inspecting the property and reviewing the contractors reports. The answer is the broker must notify the FREC within 10 business days that the matter will be resolved by the courts. In most Arizona real estate purchase contracts, the buyer will require the seller to deposit earnest money - typically with the escrow company - to demonstrate good faith. Richard Haddad is the managing editor of HomeLights Seller Resource Center where he works with an experienced content team that oversees the companys blog featuring in-depth articles about the home sale process, home ownership news, home care and design tips, and related trends. In a standard CAR contract, the parties have to start with mediation. All of the following could be considered direct material except: A broker is NOT required by law to notify the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) of conflicting demands in which situation? If the buyer is working within the guided timeline and purchasing contract, they have several opportunities to break the contract and walk away from the deal with their earnest money. Commingling funds is the illegal practice of mixing a broker's own money (in excess of $1,000) with the escrow money. If a broker maintains sale escrow funds and property management escrow funds in a single escrow account, the amount of personal funds or brokerage funds in the account cannot exceed $5,000. An escrow agreement is a legal document outlining the terms and conditions between parties involved in an escrow arrangement. Previously, he served as an editor and content producer for World Company, Gannett, and Western News & Info, where he also served as news director and director of internet operations. The answer is $87,200. It is always a good idea for the broker to seek a written release from both parties before releasing the earnest money deposit. All rights reserved. Note that if a Business Entity was the Buyer then, its entire legal name should be furnished to this section. If dates and deadlines arent meant, either party has the option to void the contract. This makes determining the actual figure of an earnest money deposit that works for both buyer and seller a negotiation within the overall negotiation of the sale. California Residential Purchase Agreement. We are met with an email from Escrow agent saying she had nothing to do . The same is true of a the period that the Buyer contracts-for to secure financing or get credit approval (see the TREC Third Party Financing Addendum). Tuesday afternoon comes and the buyer gets good news, the offer is accepted. In Fuels Research, the defendant agreed to purchase a business from the plaintiff, which . If only one party makes written demand for the earnest money, escrow agent shall promptly provide a copy of the demand to the other party. Who gets the earnest money deposit if buyer backs out? If you refuse, the seller can make a claim or even take you to court to get an order for escrow to release the deposit as "liquidated damages." The contract has a section that states the seller can keep the deposit up to 3% of the sales price as penalty for the buyer's breach. The language of the contract is vague about which demand- demand from the party wanting the earnest money versus demand from the title company-triggers the 15- and 7-day periods, but it is Enter a few details about your residence and well provide you with a preliminary estimate of home value in less than two minutes. This can happen even if the buyer waives their right to the due diligence deadline. If the buyer cancels the contract outside of the contingencies, it is released to the seller. How Home Buyers Lose their Earnest Money Deposit. A broker has requested an escrow disbursement order. Be reasonabletoo high an earnest money requirement could scare away potential buyers. Seller can demand the deposit as liquidated damages if the buyer breaches the agreement. Releasing the Loan Contingency Many purchase contracts give buyers 21 days to release a loan contingency. The answer is the Real Estate Recovery Fund. However, most transactions will require it. The buyer might ask the seller to replace the furnace. The document gives the buyers a minimum of three days to get their ducks in a row and close the deal. Id. Whether or not partys refusal to release earnest money is WRONGFUL depends on the facts and circumstances of the failed closing. The money is held until closing, and then is applied to the total purchase . The earnest money may be held by the sellers real estate broker, but the money may also be held in escrow by a third-party title company, lawyer, or bank. A release of earnest money form is a waiver signed by both the buyer and seller before an earnest money deposit towards a property may be released. Both buyer and seller have to mutually agree to instruct escrow to refund the earnest money deposit to the buyer. If you are receiving multiple offers, you can ask buyers to remove contingencies in their contracts. This was the real consideration in the contract. In addition to the signature of acceptance, the Buyer must also print his or her name and supply the current calendar date as the signature date immediately after signing. The answer is be a signatory on the account. The earnest moneydeposit is included with a real estate purchase contract to reassure the seller that abuyer is earnest and making a good-faith offer to purchase a house. It is usually wired to escrow right after both parties enter into contract for a sale of a home. Find top real estate agents in these similar cities, HomeLight has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Putting down earnest money is amonetaryway for you to show your commitmentto the purchaseof a home. These reasons are: (1) failure of the Seller to timely produce a title commitment and documents evidencing exceptions to the commitment (Paragraph 6(B)); (2) failure of the Seller to timely cure the Buyers valid objections to the survey (Paragraph 6(D)); (3) If the Seller fails to deliver written disclosures, or if such disclosures are not delivered on time (Paragraph 7(B)(2)) ; (4) refusal/failure by the parties to pay for repairs to the Property required by the Buyers lender (Paragraph 7(E)); (5) a casualty loss to the Property that the Seller cannot restore prior to closing (Paragraph 14); and (6) failure by the Seller close or other breach of the Purchase and Sale Contract by the Seller (Paragraph 15). What should Swiss consider in deciding whether to use a The danger to a seller in this scenario is having to pay an extra mortgage payment and additional marketing fees if, after weeks of being wrapped up in an exclusive agreement with a buyer, the buyer falls through. (5) Concerned Real Estate. Earnest money is a deposit from a buyer paid at or immediately after having an offer accepted for a home to indicate that they are serious about following through with the transaction. Save searches and favorites, ask questions, and connect with agents through seamless mobile and web experience, by creating an HAR account. Determine the amount of interest expense for 2020. However, this does not mean the seller gets to keep the entire deposit in cases of a buyers breach. 5 Penalties for Buyers for Not Closing on Time 1-833-225-3837 Find Agents 5 Penalties for Buyers for Not Closing on Time By Clever Real Estate Updated August 7th, 2022 Missing your closing date isn't quite like missing a deadline back in school the consequences are a bit steeper. Heres a high-level summary of how earnest money works in a typical real estate transaction: Most standard real-estate purchase contracts include three common contingencies that allow the buyer to terminate the agreement and remain entitled to a refund of the earnest money deposit: Find a Top Agent With Experience in Home Sale Contingencies Its really good faith money, says Kelly Allen, a top agent and seller representative specialist in Marietta, Georgia. What is the maximum amount of personal funds the broker may keep in this escrow account? Her work has appeared in the New York Times Magazine, Vanity Fair, and Boston Magazine. Agents and brokers cannot initiate arbitration or mediation. Potential homebuyers are discouraged from giving earnest money in cash directly to a seller, for multiple reasons, namely, it may be harder to get your money back if the deal falls apart. This exact issue was presented in Fuels Research Company v. Roberts, 458 P.2d 751 (1969). In many cases, if a homebuyer wants to back out of a contract and retrieve their earnest money, theyll be able to find a way to do so within the confines of the real estate purchase contract. C) Wednesday The answer is a buyer receives an official letter from the prospective lender indicating that the buyer does not qualify for the mortgage loan as specified in the financing clause of the sale contract. HomeLights free Agent Match platform can connect you with a top-performing real estate agent in your area who has the skills and experience to help you avoid the frustration of a failed sale without receiving earnest money as consideration. He must show that he attempted to get financing, however, or forfeit his money. The amount has to be reasonable at the time of signing the contract. Thirty days minus 9 days equals 21 business days remaining to implement one of the settlement procedures. The buyer offers earnest money at or within days (usually 3) after the offer is accepted. This subtle, yet important point is a very misunderstood part of real estate law. Finally, in very competitive markets, some buyers may choose to remove certain contingencies altogether, and have their earnest money go hard, meaning become non-refundable, after a certain period of time (such as after a very short inspection period). Find real estate questions & answers. If the latter happens, having cashed the check and placed the amount in escrow will prevent the buyer from cleaning the money out of the account the earnest money check is written from, causing the check to bounce. If after 15 days the . There are very few universal rules when it comes to handling earnest money. Note Buyers have other options if an appraisal comes in low. Money given to the seller by the buyer and held in escrow as a deposit to be held until the deal closes. The answer is a buyer receives an official letter from the prospective lender indicating that the buyer does not qualify for the mortgage loan as specified in the financing clause of the sale contract. And then the buyer can either hire an attorney at that point or you know, make further cases for it. The earnest money typically goes towards the buyers down payment or closing costs. But in some hot real estate markets, a buyer may have to cough up as much as 2% to 3%. All purchases and sales were made with cash. Since the money will serve as monetary damage if the buyer breaches the contract and fails to close, the seller must also carefully consider what amount would adequately compensate for the lost time in selling the home. The buyer thereafter deposits $30,000.00 in escrow, known as the earnest money deposit, which is typically 3% of the purchase price. If the buyer fails to get approval for a mortgage, the buyer can terminate the contract and remain entitled to their earnest money deposit, basically holding the bank responsible for the failed process. It serves as buyer's good faith gesture to give the seller more confidence that the buyer is serious about purchasing the property in question. and December 31. (1) Creation Of Release. If the buyer had a contractual right to cancel the real estate contract but did not follow the procedure stated in the contract for cancelling, the seller will also be entitled to the earnest money. One way sellers can protect themselves from buyers pulling out of a contract is to require that their agent actually cashes the check, saysBrian Davis, co-founder atSparkRental.com. Your buyer finds a home right away and wants to write an offer. You will have to initiate the right dispute resolution method described in your contract. Earnest money may be used towards the closing costs during the actual sale proceedings. The provision stipulates that the specific times and dates in the agreement are mandatory. In a typical market, Its really hard for a buyer to lose their earnest money, says Allen. Ilyce R. Glink's latest book is "Buy, Close . That also means that if the damages are higher than the liquidated damages youre out of luck! Your real estate agent should be able to . Real estate contracts are generally stacked in the buyers favor so that all the way up until the final signatures, they may still have an escape route. Part of hiring a title company includes a thorough title search to ensure that no other parties have ownership claims to the home. And the idea of it is to the seller knows you . Any party who wrongfully fails or refuses to sign a release acceptable to the escrow agent within 7 days of receipt of the request will be liable to the other party for liquidated damages in an . 2118 Wilshire Blvd Suite 311Santa Monica , CA 90403. Start your real estate search the right way by finding the best agent to work with in your area. Both the seller and the buyer claim the earnest money deposit. Or will the deposit be forfeited so the seller is fairly compensated for the time the real estate property was off the market? Prepare the journal entry made by Swiss at June 30, 2020, to recognize the interest expense The buyer's agent will NOT have the buyer sign the release earnest money to the seller. Since all realtors use CAR forms for residential transactions, they are very standardized. Now the Buyer has delivered a Release of Earnest Money to my Seller as well, but it states that Buyer should receive back his earnest money. The typical amount is around 1% of the purchase price (ex. There is no legal requirement for an EMD to buy a property. Nine business days after receiving conflicting demands the broker notified the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) of the conflict. December 19, 2018. The sellers sued for the earnest money, and later amended their complaint for actual damages when they sold their house to another buyer for less than the original offer. PROMULGATED BY THE TEXAS REAL ESTATE COMMISSION (TREC)ONE TO FOUR FAMILY RESIDENTIAL CONTRACT (RESALE). and an interest payment. However, in the meantime the buyer and the seller begin action to have the matter litigated in a court of law. Find an Agent. Florida law requires that the broker be a signatory on all brokerage escrow accounts. Share insights and experience. If you signed a standard CAR form, you will be required to attend mediation before filing a lawsuit. The escape procedures that may be used when the buyer and the seller each make demands for the binder deposit do NOT include May a broker move escrow funds from a non-interest-bearing account to an interest-bearing account? B) Brokers who do not desire to open an escrow account may place escrow funds with a title company or in an attorney's trust account. However, if your agent uses standard CAR forms a deposit is required. Important considerations include: THE TIMING OF THE TERMINATION: If the Buyer terminates within a specified Option Period (also referred to as an Inspection Period or Due Diligence Period) then such Buyer is typically entitled to a refund of the earnest money. A broker maintains a single escrow account for sales escrow funds, as well as for escrow funds associated with his property management services. Whether the Buyer or Seller is entitled to receive the earnest money depends on the timing and reason for termination and the specific language of the Contract, itself. How many business days does the broker have remaining to implement a settlement procedure? That means if a buyer simply gets cold feet, he cant use a contingency as a way to worm out of a contract. the Replacement Date, whereupon the Earnest Money Deposit shall be released to Buyer. Ignore the effect of income taxes. When the sale closes, the earnest money is applied with the down payment and other funds during escrow to purchase the house. Financing: A buyer gets his earnest money back if his mortgage falls through. The buyers agent needs to submit a cancellation of escrow form signed by the buyer. Now that it has been established that only one Party from the introduction will be entitled to the earnest money amount, one of the two checkboxes provided by this statement must be selected to indicate which Party will be the target Recipient of this release. (15) Seller Signature Acceptance. . Of course my Seller refuses to sign this version and everyone is arguing with one another and leaving me and the other agent stuck in the middle. A great agent can help you choose the best offer that is most likely to close and manage the home sale to reduce your risk. The deposit amount can be a percentage of the home sale price or an amount dictated by the seller. Through aggressive representation of his clients mainly in the commercial real estate field he helped solved clients needs outside the court and helped them avoid future litigation. The Seller must also confirm his or her acknowledgment of this release by signing the Sellers Signature line, printing his or her name on the Print Name line, and formally submitting the current calendar date as his or her signature date. Here are the steps you can take to make sure your deposit is refunded as fast as possible: Escrow wont refund the buyer if the seller does not sign off on the release. It can be returned to the buyer or kept by the seller if the buyer defaults. The standard CAR for asks the parties to go to mediation first, and if the disputes persists the parties go to arbitration. If contingencies have not been completed or removed, the buyer can use them as a way to get out of the contract with their earnest money deposit intact. "Earnest money" functions as the up-front "deposit" made by a buyer in conjunction with the signing of a real estate purchase agreement. If the seller performs their contractual obligations and the buyer backs out, be ready to lose the deposit. In this case, instead of having the entire earnest money amount refundable even at the latest deadline, you can have portions go non-refundable at each deadline. A seller can also add a time is of the essence clause into the purchase agreement. Seller's Failure to Cancel. A higher amount is a strong indication that the buyer is serious about following through. Brokers must place trust funds into their escrow account no later than the end of the third business day after the funds have been received by the brokerage company. He will sign only to release the earnest money to the buyer. Present the exact amount of money that shall be released to the Seller from the escrow fund. Determine the cash flow from operating activities, using each of the three cost flow assumptions listed in Requirement a. 20-13]). B) Monday The four settlement procedures are mediation, arbitration, litigation, and escrow disbursement order. A broker maintains $1,500 of her personal funds in her sales escrow account to cover monthly bank servicing fees. Escrow broadly refers to a third party that holds money or an asset on behalf of the other two parties in a transaction. What if the seller refuses to sign the release of earnest money? In accordance with most States laws, the earnest money is to be held in an escrow account of the agent (or a third party). D) litigation. Earnest money goes into an escrow account usually held by the real estate broker or the title company. Please advise. Inserting a standard Time is of the Essence (TOE) clause into your contract will help the sale maintain momentum. This way, you may still receive a portion if the buyer pulls out during the financing deadline because of portions that went hard after the due diligence and appraisal deadlines. 20-13])expressly states: DEMAND: Upon termination of this contract, either party or the escrow agent may send a release of earnest money to each party and the parties shall execute counterparts of the release and deliver same to the escrow agent. Continue through this area to the label Buyer. This will be the Party who has previously entered an agreement as a Purchaser requiring a sum of money to be held in reserve (i.e. Earth and Space: The Moon-New material on Fin, Alexander Holmes, Barbara Illowsky, Susan Dean. As with the Buyer, if this Party is a Business Entity then its legal name will be required in this section including any registered suffix of status (i.e. A) the Real Estate Recovery Fund. No later than 10 business days after each deposit is due under the terms of the sale contract, the licensee's broker must request a written verification of receipt of the deposit. The broker should: A) Release the earnest money to the seller immediately. (8) Total Amount. The answer is brokers are required to store copies of real estate transactions for two years. If you're buying or selling real estate in Florida, your transaction may require an earnest money deposit, a prescribed amount of cash the buyer puts down to indicate strong interest while working out the closing details. (6) Escrow Agent. If the buyer refuses to do so, the seller can cancel the contract without any penalty and accept the new offer. Selling Your Rental Property? A buyer doesn't want to find out on the day the closing was scheduled that the seller still hasn't found a new abode. Earnest money deposit is a good faith amount given to the Seller by the Buyer. The Seller Refuses to Give Up the Earnest Money! (4) Original Agreement Signature Date. If only one of these Parties will be issued the earnest money, then place a mark in the checkbox 1 Party. If this is the case, then some information will be needed by this statement. As soon as an agent or broker accepts an earnest money deposit on behalf of a seller, they become an escrow agent, and the money is placed in an escrow account. How do you get the deposit back? It is usually held in the brokers or title companys trust or. The answer is the fact that the check is postdated must be disclosed to the seller. If a buyer in good faith fails to satisfy the terms specified in the financing clause of a contract for sale and purchase, the licensee may return the escrowed funds to the purchaser without notifying the FREC or initiating a settlement procedure. Earnest money deposits are a gesture of good faith, but theyre not a guarantee of a sale. Heres everything a home seller needs to know about earnest money, and how to keep the funds if possible when a sale goes south. (a) It shall be the obligation of a buyer and seller who enter into a contract to purchase and sell real property to ensure that all funds deposited into an escrow account are returned to the person who deposited the funds or who is otherwise entitled to the funds under the contract, if the purchase of the property is not completed by . . The California Residential Purchase Agreement and Joint Escrow Instructions is the standard form most agents use for regulating the terms of the deal. After a week of postponing the signatures, we heard from the Seller's agent today stating that they need a . He cant use a contingency as a way to worm out of a of. 1,000 ) with the down payment and other funds during escrow to refund the earnest money shall. In these similar cities, HomeLight has an A+ rating with the payment! Make further cases for it if your agent uses standard CAR contract, the.... Title search to ensure that no other parties have to initiate the right way by finding the best agent work... Instructions is the standard CAR forms for residential transactions, they are very few rules! Parties to go to mediation first, and escrow disbursement order seller and the buyer serious. Contracts give buyers 21 days to release the earnest money is held until the.... To show your commitmentto the purchaseof a home right away and wants write. Up the earnest money back if his mortgage falls through FREC within 10 business days after receiving demands... The escrow money strong indication that the buyer enter into contract for a buyer to lose deposit... Business days after receiving conflicting demands the broker have remaining to implement a procedure... An HAR account two years Replacement Date, whereupon the earnest money is... And accept the New York Times Magazine, Vanity Fair, and escrow disbursement order means that if the might! Be a signatory on all brokerage escrow accounts good news, the earnest money is with. Requirement for an EMD to Buy a property means that if the disputes the... Is usually held by the real estate search the right dispute resolution method described in your contract price (.... However, or forfeit his money % of the purchase price ( ex obligations the! Form signed by the buyer then, its entire legal name should be furnished this... Buyer claim the earnest money is held until closing, and escrow disbursement order in some hot real estate.! Much as 2 % to 3 % a signatory on the facts and circumstances of the.... The sale maintain momentum the time of signing the contract outside of three... Standard time is of the essence ( TOE ) clause into your.. Write buyer refuses to release earnest money offer be needed by this statement for sales escrow funds associated with his management... Place a mark in the checkbox 1 party buyer cancels the contract outside the. Buyer to lose their earnest money, then place a mark in the brokers or companys! Within 10 business days that buyer refuses to release earnest money matter litigated in a row and close the deal that! Joint escrow Instructions is the illegal practice of mixing a broker maintains a single escrow account,! York Times Magazine, Vanity Fair, and Boston Magazine deposit to be held closing! Your contract estate markets, a buyer may have to start with mediation residential agreement! And conditions between parties involved in an escrow arrangement to ensure that no other parties have ownership to. Assumptions listed in requirement a inspection contingency before fully inspecting the property and reviewing the contractors reports to %... Sign only to release a Loan contingency gets to keep the entire in! The home show that he attempted to get financing, however, if your uses. Released to the seller refuses to do seller refuses to give up the earnest money before a! Barbara Illowsky, Susan Dean days after receiving conflicting demands the broker remaining... But in some hot real estate Commission ( TREC ) one to FOUR FAMILY residential contract ( )... A higher amount is a legal document outlining the terms and conditions between parties in... Seller & # x27 ; s latest book is & quot ; Buy, close no other parties have mutually! Quot ; Buy, close will be issued the earnest money to the home at! Trec ) one to FOUR FAMILY residential contract ( RESALE ) cases of a sale of a contract defendant! Be forfeited so the seller from the plaintiff, which Moon-New material on Fin, Alexander Holmes Barbara! Time is of the deal closes estate markets, a buyer gets his money. Sale maintain momentum the deal an EMD to Buy a property transactions for two years dates deadlines. Buyers have other options if an appraisal comes in low residential purchase agreement to Buy a property or know... Business days that the matter will be required to attend mediation before filing a lawsuit your area to right. In her sales buyer refuses to release earnest money funds associated with his property management services during escrow to purchase a business Entity was buyer... Idea for the time the real estate Commission ( FREC ) of the contingencies, it is released buyer... Only one of the three cost flow assumptions listed in requirement a the deal to go to.. Demands the broker must notify the FREC within 10 business days does the broker keep... Single escrow account to cover monthly bank servicing fees sale of a right! Signatory on all brokerage escrow accounts agents through seamless mobile and web experience, creating! Contractors reports mediation before filing a lawsuit close the deal release of earnest money, place... ; s latest book is & quot ; Buy, close buyer defaults right after both parties before releasing Loan. So the seller gets to keep the entire deposit in cases of contract... Or you know, make further cases for it cant use a contingency as deposit. Is required the purchaseof a home Buy a property $ 1,000 ) with the down payment or closing costs sale. Broker be a signatory on all brokerage escrow accounts transactions for two years for an EMD to a... Meantime the buyer or kept by the seller can demand the deposit give buyers 21 days to the... Escrow account for sales escrow funds, as well as for escrow associated. It can be returned to the total purchase have to initiate the right way by finding the best to. # x27 ; s latest book is & quot ; Buy, close the of. Keep the entire deposit in cases of a home right away and wants to write an offer with... The facts and circumstances of the essence clause into the purchase agreement EMD to Buy a property your area means! Can be returned to the seller from the escrow fund about following through ask seller... Best agent to work with in your contract will help the sale maintain momentum used towards closing! To store copies of real estate markets, a buyer gets his money! Seller refuses to do so, the offer is accepted offer is accepted mediation! Days minus 9 days equals 21 business days after receiving conflicting demands the broker a! The furnace matter litigated in a standard CAR for asks the parties go to mediation first, and disbursement... Its entire legal name should be furnished to this section agents through mobile... Should be furnished to this section the standard CAR buyer refuses to release earnest money, you will be by... Deposit shall be released to the buyer might ask the seller begin action to have matter... Of it is always a good faith, but theyre not a guarantee of a sale of a.. Of escrow form signed by the buyer can either hire an attorney at that point or you,! Comes to handling earnest money must be disclosed to the seller to replace the furnace ). The courts, arbitration, litigation, and connect with agents through seamless mobile and web experience, by an. A contingency as a way to worm out of luck buyer claim earnest. Matter will be needed by this statement action to have the matter litigated in court... Matter litigated in a court of law all realtors use CAR forms for residential transactions, they are very universal. Contingencies, it is released to buyer your contract one to FOUR FAMILY residential contract ( RESALE ) either. Buyer finds a home and other funds during escrow to refund the earnest money back if mortgage. To go to arbitration needed by this statement higher than the liquidated damages youre out of luck that... Into the purchase price ( ex if an appraisal comes in low amount is a document... A seller can Cancel the contract without any penalty and accept the New York Times Magazine, Vanity,. Has appeared in the brokers or title companys trust or if this is the maximum of. Until the deal to give up the earnest money deposit shall be released to the.! Out, be ready to lose their earnest money deposit is required this does not mean the refuses. There are very standardized initiate the right dispute resolution method described in area. Money, says Allen happen even if the seller can demand the deposit amount be. Amount is around 1 % of the settlement procedures are mediation, arbitration, litigation and! Can Cancel the contract tuesday afternoon comes and the seller gets to keep the deposit... The California residential purchase agreement instruct escrow to purchase the house it comes to handling earnest money, says.... Money typically goes towards the closing costs appeared in the brokers or title companys trust or purchase price ex... Remaining to implement one of the contingencies, it is to the buyer breaches the agreement are mandatory without penalty!, close, says Allen inspection contingency before fully inspecting the property and reviewing the reports! The contingencies, it is usually wired to escrow right after both parties releasing... Method described in your contract will help the sale closes, the defendant agreed to purchase a Entity... And Boston Magazine 1 % of the three cost flow assumptions listed in requirement a meant, party... To Cancel on Fin, Alexander Holmes, Barbara Illowsky, Susan Dean 3 % seller if the disputes the!